Best Pizza in Washington Heights

Best Pizza in Washington Heights

Outstanding New York pizza is nothing new. The best pizza in Washington Heights does a great job in representing our city! Locals and visitors alike should make a note of trying all of these pizza places. Enjoy!

We love all New York pizza! Check out the best pizza places on the Upper West Side!

Como Pizza

4035 Broadway

Fresh pizza for Columbia students! So unassuming and old school that they don’t have a website! But we like that.  Thick crust and super filling.

Best Pizza in Washington Heights

Bodega Pizza

4455 Broadway

Cool pizza place designed to look like an old school bodega, with iterations of hip hop songs, artists and local street names to title some of their menu options.

One of their more exotic slices include their “tres golpe pizza”, with salami, bacon eggs and mozzarella.

They offer whole wheat and gluten free bread for an extra $3.

Best Pizza in Washington Heights

Fresco’s Pizzeria

804 West 187th St

Fresco’s takes their ingredients seriously! They import their Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese from Italy, and let it age for 12 months before use.  Imported prosciutto, extra virgin olive oil and some of the highest quality tomatoes are also used in their pies.

Some notable pies include their fig and goat cheese, as well as “The Grandma” (pictured below).

Best Pizza in Washington Heights


Koronet Pizza

4087 Broadway

Koronet is known for their GIANT slices. Definitely no need to get more than one jumbo slice. With stellar reviews, they are popular not just for their pizza, but for their service and very reasonable prices. They have another location on the Upper West Side near Columbia University.

washington heights pizza


Charlie’s Pizza

1501 St Nicholas Ave

Small, unassuming store front with traditional New York pizza. Charlie’s has been around for a long time and is a great taste of old New York. Very low prices, too!

washington heights pizza


Antika Pizzeria

3924 Broadway

Antika’s pizza is made with New York water, flour and sea salt. Known for combining the old styles of pizza from Naples with their own take on New York pizza!

One popular pie is their Old Fashioned Grandma Style Square Cheese:  with san Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella cheese, grande mozzarella cheese, grana Padano, pecorino cheese, extra virgin olive oil & oregano. They also offer a clam, Buffalo calamari, and chipotle pizza!

Antika is a family style restaurant with plenty of additional Italian dishes on their menu!

washington heights pizza

Luigi’s Pizza

2127 Amsterdam Ave

Old school New York pizza with great prices. Small store with a friendly host! Basic, straightforward menu with everything you need.

washington heights pizza


4484 Broadway

Wahizza has rave reviews for their fresh ingredients, crispy thin crust and unique slices.

Try their super popular Chimichurri Dominican Pizza!

The Wahizza Special Pizza is also one to try, made with fresh mozzarella, oyster mushrooms, arugula, prosciutto, shake pecorino, basil, truffle oil.

They also offer pizza rolls, calzones, and cannolis.

washington heights pizza

Related Posts

The following two tabs change content below.

Mike Mishkin

Native Upper West Sider. Real estate broker and entrepreneur. Principal broker and owner of Love Where You Live Realty & owner of For all of your real estate needs, call Mike at (917) 609-8680. Learn More about Mike!

Latest posts by Mike Mishkin (see all)

Local Sponsors